AUGUST OUT NOW

mybliss.co.uk

celebs

DAILY GOSSIP

Are Kellan and Ashley out?

Trouble in the Cullen clan

With news that the fourth Twilight novel, Breaking Dawn, will be divided into two movies, Kellan Lutz and Ashley Greene are asking for a major pay rise and as a result, production of the film is on hold. Even worse, both could get the boot!

The main Twilight trio – Robert Pattinson, Kristen Stewart and Taylor Lautner – have all signed up for the final installments of the film. However, Ashley and Kellan aren't rushing to sign as quickly – both have reportedly requested $4 million each to take back on their roles as Alice and Emmett Cullen and the studio isn't happy. If a negotiation can't be reached, one or both stars could be re-cast.

Could you imagine the roles of Alice and Emmett Cullen being played by anyone else? Tell us what you think of a possible Breaking Dawn cast change.

Related stories: Ashley Greene interview / Secret Eclipse screening / Twilight channel

DAILY GOSSIP

Comments

Submitted by redyellowgreenblueJLS on 2010-05-13 17:40:13.87.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

That is sooo silly!!!! I love alice in the movies she cant't leave x

Submitted by franky101 on 2010-05-13 23:06:05.35.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOOOO!i love emmet almost as much as edward and alice is so nice!they can't recast.IT'S CRIMINAL!

Submitted by hettiemaloo on 2010-05-13 19:18:47.21.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

If they get rid of Asheley and/or Kellan, I am not going to go and see Breaking Dawn. Simple!

Submitted by XxFrizzixX on 2010-05-13 19:47:57.543.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

OMG!!!!!!! noooooooo!!! I lurve Ashley Greene!!

Submitted by Sporty Tash on 2010-05-13 21:37:32.267.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOOOO!!! That can't happen, they are Alice and Emmett, no one can replace them EVER!! But i can't believe they're asking for a pay rise that much!!!! JUST DO IT FOR THE FANS, PLEASE!!! xxxxx

Submitted by Phee on 2010-05-14 18:48:33.433.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

You can't change the parts it wouldn't be right!

Submitted by AlysConnie on 2010-05-15 11:59:05.597.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Personally, I think it is greedy of them to even ask for a raise, they were probably already getting a lot and it's not all about the money, making the film should be fun. And your doing it for the fans, why be so selfish? True, the film wouldn't be the same without them...

Submitted by aymzii98 on 2010-05-16 11:19:34.997.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Kellan and Ashley are my fave actors alongside robert pattinson, and if they go i will not go and see the BREAKING DAWN film. oh and give them a pay rise!!!!!!!!!!!!

Submitted by Cherry988 on 2010-05-16 13:07:04.487.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

why do celebrities always have to turn greedy ? Life isnt about money, they should be happy that they are a part of the greatest series ever made and the portrayal of emmet & alice; I know many people that would die for those roles.

Submitted by Ophelia on 2010-05-16 16:47:57.44.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

they can't leave it wouldn't be the same without them x

Submitted by GeorgianaC on 2010-05-16 19:05:47.63.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

THIS IS TOTALLY STUPID THEY ARE LIKE PERFECT FOR THESE ROLES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Submitted by Hezi on 2010-05-16 20:24:59.967.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

I think that is RUBISH if they get the sack!!! Someone should tell Ashley and Kellan that it isn't about the money think about all the fans. No one could replace Alice or Emmett there so brill in the films that would just be so RUBISH if the characters got changed now.

Submitted by EmmBaileyyyy on 2010-05-16 23:11:54.583.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

kmn!thats pathetic theyknow the public love them so why pull a demanding stunt like this wanting more money for there job!? do they want to seek attention from everyone because theyknow noone wants them to leave?, its all abit o.t.t ifyouask me.

Submitted by x-kimr-x on 2010-05-17 10:13:51.767.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

no way they have to stay :(

Submitted by Lulababe on 2010-05-17 19:50:32.947.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

OmG! they r like the only good actors in the whole movie! x

Submitted by sophie.cutiepie on 2010-05-19 20:53:53.82.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

That would be awful, the studio should sign them! To be honest Breaking Dawn is going to do so well anyway that it would be a loss if they were replaced. They're perfect for the roles of Alice and Emmet!! :)

Submitted by Rgirl15 on 2010-05-22 15:36:18.027.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

They shouldn't ask for so much. Fame getting to der heads. They hardly say any lines anyway.

Submitted by T-Bag on 2010-05-23 19:20:57.587.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

They ARE being kinda selfish about the money and they arne't really thinkng about thier fans. Tbh I cant actually see anyone else plaing the role of emmet or alice so they should stop being so silly ad just carry on the way it was!!!

Submitted by Holly.B on 2010-05-24 20:27:31.177.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

nooooooooooooooo kellan and ashley can't leave they are cool

Submitted by nkiliddle on 2010-05-25 21:00:47.133.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

tbf, they're being a bit greedy, they probably get loads of money anyway and they're asking for more. It will ruin all of the films if they go out. Alice's character is amazing, she's so bubbly. I'de be frineds with her anyday :) x

Submitted by Em.Lautner.xx on 2010-05-25 23:11:16.3.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

its okayy apparently they have found a good deal so they r going to b playing alice and emmett in breaking dawn!!!

Submitted by Bubbleyy.B on 2010-05-27 19:20:58.287.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

If they do leave then I will definitely NOT see any of the other films. It's O.O.O if they do because they are both funny and everything!!!!!!!!!! Please please do not have a rise until the films are over! Just for the films. Please xxxxxxx!!!!!!!!!!

Submitted by mrs.XavierSamuel. on 2010-05-29 14:15:02.417.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

I really hope that doesn't happen. :( It just wouldn't be the same. <3

Submitted by elfyrox on 2010-05-29 16:58:31.873.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOOOOO don't go ashley and kellan, all the changes are changing the movies even if they don't seem to really realise it. And btw who NEEDS $4 million i mean come on!! they must have made a fortune on the other movies and they're great for the parts!!! i can't imagine anyone else being alice especially!

Submitted by VicVicx on 2010-05-31 10:51:31.27.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Nobody could play Alice & Emmet as well as these two! Breaking Dawn is important, it's the best and a different Alice won't work! Or an Emmet, you need him the whole storyline won't be the same without them! They should just do the film for the fans! x

Submitted by RP RP x on 2010-06-01 00:22:06.45.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

I love Alice Cullen(Ashley Greene) She is my idol. And i would be devestated if her role is replaced. i also read the books before watching the films and i thought that Ashley & Kellan fit the perfect figures in my mind for Alice&Emmett. I'm completly 'ROBSESSED' And i think there roles are just as important as Robert Pattinson. God hope this is Just a rumour!!!

Submitted by RuthBonthron on 2010-06-02 00:28:45.11.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Nooo.. Kellan can't leave i dont really care bout ashley greene though. xxx

Submitted by twilghtmentalist on 2010-06-06 22:06:49.843.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

talk about selfish!!

Submitted by Baybiie.Angel-x on 2010-06-07 19:49:18.423.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

How much are they getting paid at the moment? Because if they are getting paid like, 1.5 million They`re being greedy but i can understand if it`s like, 3.5 million (: I love them both, especially Ashley, Alice is my favourite character and she can`t be replaced And Kellan, Kellan`s just fit ;DDD and i hate the idea of someone else`s body playing him ;) I`m glad the main ones have signed though but it`s still bad because it would be awkward for them to leave... x

Submitted by splodgetta on 2010-06-08 20:52:15.68.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

I heard that Taylor got quite a lot in the first film and he wasn't in it that much. So i think it is fair that they try and get a better pay.

Submitted by BethTwiliHeidi on 2010-06-11 21:51:28.76.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

They can't be recast!!!!!! It was bad enough recasting Rachelle Lefevre for Bryce Dallas Howard (we'll see how that turns out...) but Kellan and Ashley need to be in it!!! You can't change them now!!!! Any cast changes and i will literally protest against Summit.

Submitted by lozzamatoz1995 on 2010-06-12 09:37:33.58.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Omdz no... if they leave then it won't be emmett and alice any more... so I won't find the film as effective to be honest.

Submitted by TeamEdward.x on 2010-06-14 19:00:49.327.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

It might be a lot of money they're asking for but its a big role they're taking on! they deserve it! And its a big success! They're such great characters, they cant leave!! x

Submitted by bok on 2010-06-14 21:38:47.913.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

i think they should stop being so bleddy greedy. they have a job millions of people would only dream of and they're making themselves look like spoilde brats by taking even more. its shameful.

Submitted by MrsPattinson xx on 2010-06-15 20:56:58.6.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOO!!! Kellan lutz is soo fit, and ashley greene is just awesome xx

Submitted by AshleighBob01 on 2010-06-16 17:28:22.99.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

This is Stupid! they cant boot Kellan and Ashley, they make the characters who they are! Even though it is like...Majourly greedy i mean $4 million! But to keep the film in consistency they are needed! Im not going to see BD if Ashley and Kellan arent in it soo, DO IT FOR US PLEASE!!!

Submitted by Bee...x on 2010-06-17 17:12:16.78.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

why are they asking for more?! I hope they don't leave! :/ x

Submitted by kizzy bom bom on 2010-06-19 00:17:38.1.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

thats just stupid asking for a pay rise like that even if they do change the actors im still going to see the movies its just pathetic that they would disrupt to films that a lot of fans depend on and look forward to!!!!!!!!!!!!

Submitted by Stefaniduncann on 2010-06-19 20:06:41.08.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

This is so stupid, they can't change two of the main characters for the last film? :S Thats so stupid!

Submitted by Adrianna on 2010-06-20 10:37:00.733.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

There could me a fitter emmett but Alice is to beautiful :)x

Submitted by Myzah on 2010-06-23 23:35:53.383.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

i dont think anyone could ever replace emmett and alice. der jus too good (;

Submitted by CjCurry on 2010-06-25 19:48:23.387.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

i cant imagine anyone else playing alice :( the movie is such a great hit, if alice goes, so do the viewers! :( xx

Submitted by skoo on 2010-06-25 17:29:58.88.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

I think that changing the actors for majors roles such as Alice and Emmett would totally change and possibly ruin the film :( When Rachelle Lavern was replaced as Victoria it wasn't so bad but Alice and Emmett? No way. I think they're asking alot but i hope they stay x

Submitted by lankyshaza on 2010-06-26 12:32:11.597.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOOOO! they can't recast for Emmet and Alice! they are both excellent actors who play the part well! they have already filmed the first three films u cant just change the actors :'( the film won't be the same without the origional main cast!!!! x

Submitted by Luvtwilightandparamore on 2010-06-26 23:18:49.583.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

noooo without Alice and Emmet it's it's............ like having cake without custard

Submitted by fran110 on 2010-06-27 18:19:17.053.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

That is so anoying. They are both amazing. The film will be incomplete without them. They earn loads already. Iwould love to bo in their shoes.

Submitted by dowdy on 2010-06-28 19:01:04.787.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Ashley and Kellen are amazing and i could not imagine any one else playing Alice or Emmett, this is a silly thing to do because they obviously know how much their fans love them an it will not be the same without them please stay Ashley and Kellen!!!!! xx

Submitted by ShaunaChicck on 2010-06-28 19:59:00.627.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Omg i love Ashley Greene ! Kellan Lutz is great i dont want im 2 go x

Submitted by twilightfan98 on 2010-06-28 19:56:39.693.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

thhat isn't truee they told other magazines that it isn't true x

Submitted by vicky steinbeck on 2010-06-29 12:21:24.143.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

omg!! i won't go see it if it's re-cast!...... well maybe for taylors abs but it won't be the same!! they are excatly the way i thaught the carictors would be and it just wouldn't be right without them!! and i mean the movies make enough money for them to get a bit more money! :(

Submitted by Lorna765 on 2010-06-29 22:02:16.687.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

:o I think Ashley Greene is perfect as Alice Cullen! She's just how I imagined her when I first read the books :l It won't be the same with someone else

Submitted by Princess MRS Cullen on 2010-07-02 23:16:48.99.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

it wouldn't be the same and plus i would still watch it i mean i love ashley and kellan playing alice and emmett cullen ashley is really pretty and emmett has good muscles :) x

Submitted by kolakid on 2010-07-03 12:56:11.583.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

If they leave the films wont b worth watching coz they bring life 2 the movies

Submitted by Hazzabo on 2010-07-03 19:02:21.093.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO i hope they dont leave their awsome, the Twilight crew it wouldent be the same :o

Submitted by Little Ray on 2010-07-03 21:00:15.47.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOOOOOO!!!!!! DONT GIVE THEM THE BOOT!!!! it wont be same without them :( !!!!!! <3

Submitted by ChelsieDaniels on 2010-07-04 11:45:28.293.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOOOOOOOOOO i love ashley greene she is better than K-Stew i don't want her to leave! QAnd my little bro loves Emmett!

Submitted by EmzzzPiglet on 2010-07-04 17:19:30.907.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

That is ridiculous of them! On the other hand, if they are recast then I am not going to see Breaking Dawn. I was really looking forward to it as it is the best book and so will hopefully be the best film, but it won't be if they're not in it!!!!!

Submitted by V1CK1 on 2010-07-04 20:43:50.133.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

i Hope Ashley and Kellan Dont leave they are totally awesome in the movie and Kellan the way he says his lines is cool DONT RECAST PLEASE!!

Submitted by twilightfanatic15 on 2010-07-04 21:56:40.477.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

omg no! they can't replace them it wouldn't be the same without them! they can't split the cullen family!

Submitted by Alice x 2010 on 2010-07-05 18:01:08.87.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

It isn't fair for the fans ! They won't find anyone who is as bouncy as Ashley or who is as physically perfect like Kellan is. In the book Emmett is described as huge and strong and they won't find anyone better for that part than Kellan ! They deserve a raise ! In Breaking dawn Alice is in half of the scenes !

Submitted by i.love.R-Pattz on 2010-07-05 19:40:12.727.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NO NO NO NO NOO!!! Theyy HAVVEE to be in Breaking Dawn. It won't be AT ALL the samee :'(

Submitted by Miss Manning on 2010-07-05 22:53:59.383.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

:O they cant kick them out.... alice and emmet wouldnt be the same without kellan and ashley, the twilight fans will be very annoyed and disappointed. they should just negotiate and NOT kick them out!!! CULLEN CLAN FOREVER x

Submitted by Hazzle on 2010-07-06 21:58:27.447.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

noooo they cant do that, they need to wise up, they are great in twilight, its what made them as famous as they are so unless they wanna sink back into a world of nothing they should sign for breaking dawn part one and two! xx

Submitted by Twlight on 2010-07-07 15:32:17.087.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

I love love love the main Twilight trio!!! I would also love love love Ashley and Kellan if they were really smart and took the roles for Alice and Emmet Cullen! However, I 'd much rather Ashley and Kellan got the boot than RPatz or KStew or TLautz!! I mean, seriously I love Ashley so don't quit but... THANK GOD RPATZ IS IN!!!

Submitted by megirl232 on 2010-07-07 18:40:05.627.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

there just silly they dont need more money they probably got alot all ready so they should get on with the show so us fans can watch them

Submitted by Ananna on 2010-07-08 20:40:25.03.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOOO ! They Can't Leave ! They Are Part Of The Twilight Family =(

Submitted by Danni149 on 2010-07-09 17:00:16.43.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

You can't change the cast at this stage! It will ruin the film and the atmopshere of it! Ashley Greene and Kellan Lutz have to stay!

Submitted by rachie321 on 2010-07-10 11:42:28.557.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

omg really!

Submitted by garbutt on 2010-07-11 12:47:03.397.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

If they both got replaced then it would be really bad.... but even worse if it was alice!!

Submitted by amazing bob on 2010-07-11 13:25:09.303.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOOOOOOOOO they can't get rid of them Alice and Emmett are my fave charcters and no on else could play them...KELLAN LUTZ IS FITx They are making breaking dawn a film? yesssss

Submitted by ilovetwilight96 on 2010-07-12 20:52:47.623.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

nooooooooooo they cant it wouldnt be the same its alice and emmet people alice and emmet are the ones that basically are main ones in cullen family part from edward woooooooooo i love r.pattz but they cant go it wouldnt be right xxx

Submitted by Priincessxtwilight on 2010-07-15 00:40:35.61.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

I read another article on this and there in the fourth film...they sorted it out...thank godness...Alice is the best...!

Submitted by JJJX on 2010-07-15 11:43:36.99.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

omg, if they re-cast these 2 stars i am NNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOTTTTTTTTTT gonna be happy. ashley and Kellan r really good at playin Alice and Emmet! I love alice and if theyre gonna change her I am sure all Twilight Saga fans will not be impressed. the same with Kellan, no 1 could possibly replace him! PLEASE DONT RE-CAST THEM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Submitted by TwilightFan1998 on 2010-07-20 17:26:33.607.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

OMG!!!! I hope the production don't boot either of them! Twilight won't be the same without them. Ashley Greene & Kellan Lutz can't leave, Ashley is one my fave actress' in the Twilight saga and Kellan is soooooo good at playing Emmett. I can't believe they're asking for £4 MILLION for their parts in the 4th & 5th movies, it's waaaayyyy too much for the parts they play- On a gud point, TWILIGHT ROX!!! xxx

Submitted by mrs.twilight on 2010-07-21 11:05:07.767.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

OOOMMMMMMFFFGGGGGGG WAT THE HELL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! U CANT REPLACE ASHLEY AN KELLAN..GREEDY BAD PEOPLE...Y CANT THEY JUST B HAPPY WITH THE MONEY THEY GOT!

Submitted by mrs.twilight on 2010-07-21 09:56:18.473.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

O.M.G i cant not get my head aroung this alice and emmett are two of my fav. give them there money and make sure breaking dawn lives up to the book

Submitted by Bieber97 on 2010-07-22 14:30:29.763.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

i dont want them to leave ! but its stupid for them to want soo much money ! they wont be able to be replaced, it wornt be right xx

Submitted by Spiderpig17 on 2010-07-22 16:02:34.48.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

What?! Thats just stupid! Think of all the Twilight fans! You can't let THEM down! Like me and everyother Twihard person! :'( Alice is my favourite character and Emmett is just so cool, so full of energy! Come on Ashley and Kellan, think about your fans! You CANT let them down!

Submitted by Neffo. on 2010-07-22 19:40:16.847.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

No, it wouldn't be the same! It's like saying what would chocolate be like without the coco beans? You couldn't do it, But also $4 million is a bit much, don't you think? ") xx

Submitted by tabizzle on 2010-07-24 15:43:14.893.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

nooooooooooooooooo! no no no no no! they cant be replaced theyre 2 of my fave characters!

Submitted by Rose101 on 2010-07-24 15:41:03.967.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

This is really wrong, it wouldn't be the same without Kellan and Ashley.They really suit the descriptions in the books and i don't think they could find anyone as good as these two. I think that less people will go to watch it if they don't appear on it.

Submitted by smileyMuse on 2010-07-24 21:23:48.03.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

nooo it wouldn't beee the same they have to stay x

Submitted by molliver on 2010-07-24 22:04:17.877.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

OMG!!! noooo!!! if ashley and kellan didnt play then it wouldnt be the same!! you have to have the same people in it otherwise it just wouldnt be twilight as all us massive fans know. personally, i think it would ruin the effect of the way that all of the people who played the cullens were there for it all the way through. all of them together make twilight to be as it is!! think about all the fans! xx

Submitted by MissyMay on 2010-07-25 14:02:47.15.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NO WAY!!! Twilight isn't complete without them! STAY!

Submitted by Twilightwolfie on 2010-07-26 00:57:10.587.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

i think if they both got booted off it would be really different and wouldnt b as good with out fit buff emmett :D and fashion mad alice :D lol i dont want them to go to b honest i dont think they should have got the new victoria shes good at it and that but you can really tell that its not the same actor and shes totally different owell 'decisions decisions' <jane

Submitted by MissyMay on 2010-07-26 10:14:13.32.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NO WAY!!!! Twilight isn't complete without them! DON'T DO IT KELLAN AND ASHLEY! Someone PLEASE make them stay!!!!!

Submitted by Sugar.xx on 2010-07-27 11:45:36.88.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Noooooooo, They Can't Replace Kellan!!!! He's Tooo Fitt To Be Replaced!!!

Submitted by MissTwilight765 on 2010-07-27 13:12:47.377.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

You cant replace Alice or Emmet!!!! The actors are like perfect for the role & it would mean holding of the film even longer, how long do they expect us to wait!?

Submitted by BubblyAmeey on 2010-07-28 16:50:31.867.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

it would be stupid to change them now especially as it is the final book, they are major characters you'd notice the difference, if they do get the boot i would think that the film wouldn't be as popular

Submitted by JJ1997 on 2010-07-30 16:19:59.337.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Thats not right Ashley and Kellan cant leave know one would want to see it. Its like if Rob, Kristen or Taylor left the show would so not be the same.

Submitted by Littlemisstwilightfreak on 2010-07-30 21:02:09.847.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Whats the point just give them the money if they kicked them out i wont go to see it ........... They all ready mucked up with the new victoria , i love the actress but it just didnt work for me and i dnt want a new alice or Emmett there perfect for it

Submitted by Random Vic x on 2010-08-01 10:39:54.597.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NO they couldn't do that, that would be a horrible way to end the saga as it would be like a totally different movie ! i think Ashley and Kellan are being greedy but if that's the way they wanna play it the studio is going to have to because they want their film to work right ? It's not all about the money! this has been an amazing opportunity for them and personally i would of done it for free so DONT GO!

Submitted by BellaSwanxoxo on 2010-08-01 23:26:17.307.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Thats sooo stupid!!! The studio should just give them the money!!!! Can u imagine a diffrent Alice and Emmett!!! Ahhhhhhhhh!!! *Faint*!!! NO They must STAY!!!!

Submitted by TaliMichelle.X. on 2010-08-03 23:40:12.633.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOOOOOO! Oh my gosh i LOVE Ashley Greene she is just TOO immense, if she goes twilight will never be the same!!,, Same for Kellen Lutz he is one of the funkiest vampires EVER and he is TOTALLY cute,, but not a cut as Robert Pattinson,, Woopppp to all u pattinson faanns!!! TEAM EDWARD ALL THE WAY!!! I mean come on vampire would be much more fun to be that a werewolf !!! :) xxxxxxx

Submitted by twilight lova 4eva on 2010-08-06 16:37:37.03.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

OMG!! they can't get somone else to play alice. ashley greene is so quirkey and just how alice is described in the books! and I mean no one can play emmett the way kellan lutz does!! if other they are re-casted breaking dawn will be no way as good as the other films!! I hope they can negotiate and still keep all origanal actors!!

Submitted by aammeelliiaa on 2010-08-07 13:57:30.207.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

:( nooo! i love alice!

Submitted by beth123 on 2010-08-07 16:57:59.3.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

omg this is sooo stupid!!! the main charecters have signed up 2 do it again but these 2 just want more money! its so stupid!!! i cant believe it! i dont want another alice emmet! i love them both!

Submitted by hayleywilliamsfan on 2010-08-08 12:28:23.207.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

no..alice ..dont go i love you <3!!!!

Submitted by bob-is-cool on 2010-08-08 22:29:35.937.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

It wouldnt be the same if they Re-cast Alice

Submitted by lovetwilightandbliss on 2010-08-09 10:59:14.78.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

no way! :O Ashley is perfect for the character of alice! she is one of my fav actress' now after seeing her in the twilight saga! i'd be gutted if she left!! x

Submitted by Elisa1993 on 2010-08-11 07:15:45.037.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

I think it's rediculous, you cant change ANY of the cast now, everyone knows that Kellan and Ashley are the cast for Alice and Emmett. Just make a compromise instead of booting them both off or all hell will break loose because of it by all the Twi-hard Fans.

Submitted by Jess0654 on 2010-08-11 21:36:11.147.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

OMG NO ONE CAN DO THAT THERE SHOULD BE A LAW ABOUT THAT OR SOMETHING I MEAN IT'S A CRIME!!! and i love Ashley Greene no one could ever be as good as alice as her and i love Kellan Lutz too no one could ever replace him as emmet either it would be insane so i beg the producers on behalf of all the twi-hard fans out their please don't replace either of them as they mean so much to all of us and they seem to enjoy it so much too please you would just be breaking all of our hearts as well as theirs so please don't do this but ashley and kellan you both are being a bit gready with money i mean you both make more money then most people and have an amazing job so you should be thankfull for that but i still love you both!!!! Xx

Submitted by GeorgianaC on 2010-08-11 23:00:07.807.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

WHAT ARE THE PRODUCERS THINKIN!!!!! They are the only people anyone could ever imagine to play them!!!! AHHHHHHHHH... I just hope they stay...... ByeSSSSS

Submitted by hot shot holz on 2010-08-13 02:05:52.4.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

OMG nothing would be the same wihout them i dont want them to leave nooooooo , AND THY ARE SO PERFECT FOR THEM ROLES !!! THEY GOTTA STAY! Gve them a pay rise .. xx

Submitted by LoLoBGee on 2010-08-13 13:46:18.307.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

AAAAAAHHH noooooo that cant happen i <3 ashley but at least T-Laut will be in it i luv him sooooo much he is well fit mann xxx

Submitted by cookiecat on 2010-08-13 20:18:00.83.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

no that cant happen it wont be the same !

Submitted by JBfanxxx on 2010-08-14 12:00:44.467.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

we r onto the last film now!! an they have had them as their characters all the way thru the saga so theyre 2 far in to change them!!!!! they cnt get rid of them i lurvv ashley greene as alice she makes the part!!

Submitted by Cupcakexox on 2010-08-14 15:43:57.34.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

OMG they cant do that ! Kellan is sooo fit xx

Submitted by chelsy on 2010-08-14 17:33:55.183.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

they cant recast alice and emmett!!! The film would be rubbish without them but i cant believe they want a pay rise of that much!!!

Submitted by Madzii on 2010-08-15 09:22:32.943.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Alice is a great character if she leaves the film wont be as good anymore :(

Submitted by Bexie-Alice Cullen on 2010-08-16 12:46:43.25.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

OMG this is stupid!!! i luv Alice and Ashley Greene! who can replace those 2? they will hav 2 find more people very soon as they start filmin in november!!! :(

Submitted by indiia on 2010-08-17 19:00:57.36.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

they cnt go

Submitted by Jazzy Brit on 2010-08-18 16:33:22.817.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

They can't leave i love them both xx

Submitted by TwilightLover2010 on 2010-08-19 18:13:28.033.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

No one can replace Ashley and Kellan. They were really awesome in Twilight, New Moon and Eclipse. I wont see both Breaking Dawn movies if they arn't in it. It'll be pointless. I cant imagine who would be a better Alice and Emmett. Ashley and Kellan belong as Alice and Emmett.

Submitted by zoe grace on 2010-08-20 16:23:18.453.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

the film would't be the same with out them but they r just being greedy and r holding up wat will be the best film ever.

Submitted by Aimsbbz on 2010-08-21 20:44:34.497.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

i think it is ridiculous and the role of alice and emmet cullen should remain the same we love the cullen clan

Submitted by xxhazel97xx on 2010-08-22 10:25:57.44.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NOOOOO they cant go, it wouldn't be the same without them xxx

Submitted by Maxigoth on 2010-08-22 14:04:02.743.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NO NO NO NO...... Just no, it will totally destroy the movie

Submitted by muckymagoo on 2010-08-22 18:07:34.367.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

noooooo! we can't lose them!!!! the movie wouldn't be as good

Submitted by billy.bob7 on 2010-08-22 22:32:18.747.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

their characters will never be acted out the same ever again!1 plz don't leave!!!!!!!!!!!!!!x

Submitted by kaaay-jaaay on 2010-08-24 16:56:30.257.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

ashley and kellan shouldn't have the same amount as Taylor Rpatz and Kristen there not as big charecters in the films but it would be weird to have different people as alice and emmett

Submitted by Mrs.JHale on 2010-08-25 13:12:27.353.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

alice really cant leave ywilihgt...she makes it real !!!!!!!!xxx

Submitted by Ellehunni on 2010-08-25 13:23:58.33.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

I they cant recast them it would be weird with a diffrent emmett and Alice but they do have the same manajor I think so maybe the manjajor suggested this as the films are a huge succsesss xx

Submitted by iz on 2010-08-25 14:35:49.463.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

NO! This can't happen, it wouldn't be the same at all! :(

Submitted by AmyGal999 on 2010-08-25 18:23:52.243.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

This CANNOT happen. It will ruin the whole thing! I don't know wether I could go and see it without these two returning to their roles in the last movie which, in fact, is my favourite book. x

Submitted by HollyyyLouiseee on 2010-08-26 00:28:21.073.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

They can't change the characters.... errrrrrrrrrrr.... it will just ruin it!!!

Submitted by Plait on 2010-08-26 14:27:42.593.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

They can't recast it would ruin the film!!!

Submitted by Natty Noo on 2010-08-26 21:03:24.71.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

No one could replace alice and emmett. That's all there is to it!

Submitted by Joesbury on 2010-08-27 16:09:08.577.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

thats wrong!!!!!!! they have to play them! it wont be the same without them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Submitted by kkk on 2010-08-30 21:29:09.43.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

noooooooooo

Submitted by Leeaz on 2010-08-30 22:23:18.997.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Noo waay, it wouldnt look right with someone else :S Itd be the worse thing EVER to replace them =(

Submitted by NicoleMLutz on 2010-08-31 09:50:44.287.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Okay- These two are literally perfect for the roles of Emmett and Alice. Despite being a bit on the greedy side, how can they ((Kellan)) let down the obsessed ones that are out there? Argh, just give them the flippin' rise. You can afford it, what with the money the films are making, right? BD won't be the same without them. -.- xx

Submitted by xbeccax1997 on 2010-08-31 17:44:16.587.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

Thats stupid, ino its alot of money to give well pay them but how cud anyone recast them just think about it, ........... its like replacing edward well not tht drastic but somewhat similar

Submitted by Amazin7 on 2010-09-02 12:20:19.587.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

That is sooo stupid they are both good actors but im not being funny though they get payed loads and each of them have about four lines in the films :P

Submitted by Miss England on 2010-09-04 20:39:23.947.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

They CAN NOT be replaced!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Submitted by hollie x on 2010-09-06 21:20:24.957.

RE: Trouble in the Cullen clan

if they leave, it's just totally confusing plus the acting in scenes would be kinda bad coz the new actor/actors would not have chemistry with the current Twilight cast.